I personally have had great dealings with Wind's customer service, when I was a Wind customer. Granted, some of the CSR's I talked to where not as helpful, but generally they where great. I used the network builder tool they have on their website to report any network problems I had. The network techs always followed up with me once the area was improved. When I reported a serious network problem in downtown Calgary. Wind's CSR's and techs contacted me frequently until the problem was resolved. I have recommended Wind to my family and friends. The ones that have signed up, have all had excellent service so far. They are happy they are saving so much money over what they used to pay with the big three. I would still be a Wind customer if I didn't want an iPhone 4 so badly. If Apple makes a future iPhone that is compatible with Wind's network, I would go back in a heart beat.
You would not see any of this helpfulness, that I received from Wind, with the big three. I have dealt with the CSR's at Bell, Telus, and Rogers over the years, and I have always had problems with them. Most of them wanted to get you off of the phone as quick as possible.
I do agree that Hugh's situation is terrible, but I also agree with the posters who commented that there should have been pros listed in his review. Even if he listed the plans as a pro, that would have been better than nothing. He knew what the plans where, and how much better they are than the big three's prices. Even if he didn't know anything about their actual network service.