Canadian TV, Computing and Home Theatre Forums banner

1 - 17 of 17 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,986 Posts
Discussion Starter #1
I'd like to hear some general experiences from existing Wind Mobile subscribers regarding network coverage in the GTA (I'm most interested in the west end of Mississauga), including call quality/dropped calls and building penetration i.e. office buildings, basements.

My longtime contract with Rogers is finally expiring, and in exploring what the various (newer) mobile carriers have to offer, Wind appears to have what I'm looking for from a plan and pricing standpoint. However, in doing my diligence in terms of online research, the opinions I've read (in other forums and the Wind community pages) have been quite mixed in terms of network coverage.

I've checked coveragemapper, which looks ok in general, although there seem to be quite a few pockets of dead zones in Mississauga.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
505 Posts
When it works it works well, but I would say that I experience more drops than I prefer. I also find that the signal strength is lower than I would expect when inside buildings, etc. I love the price, but the reliability leaves a little bit wanting. I should note that I have one of their cheapest phones, so it could be that I'm experiencing issues that I would not on a better phone.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,818 Posts
The phone makes a huge difference.
I have (usable) signal with my nexus one, where my (crap) gravity 2 would say no service.

I've generally had a positive experience.
Basements can be bad (depends on distance from tower, and again, phone)
Concrete buildings are killer (again, depends on distance and phone).

I'm impressed with how well the signal travels, despite the (relatively) sparse towers available.
In my house, the nearest tower is 1.6km away. 2nd floor, I get 3-4 bars and 1-2mbps data.
1st floor, 2-3 bars, 1-2mbps
basement, 0-1 (note that an android 0 = still connected and functional), 0.5-1mbps

That's not bad for 1.6km..

<500m from a tower, or really high up (e.g. 10th floor at work, probably 1km to tower) I get a good 3mbps, if not 5.

I haven't had a dropped call since April 2010.
Call quality has been excellent, though it depends on the phone on the other end. (I have some people call me who are using one of the big 3 [I don't know which one, not self censoring :p] and every single time it is horrendous and breaking up, regardless of where they are - and it's not my end of the connection, does the same with landline to their cell)
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
28 Posts
I work in the west end of Mississauga and I live in Burlington and I have no problem with coverage. The signal strength has always been great and I don't remember the last time I ever had a dropped call. I have the Motorola XT720. If I compare my situation to my brother, he is also on WIND and experienced a lot of dropped calls. He got a better phone and he has had no issues since. As a previous poster mentioned, the phone plays a big part in your reception. If you get a cheap phone then be prepared for dropped calls.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
12 Posts
i've been on WIND for a year, N900. i'm mostly in the SQ1 and airport areas.

i've had issues with the data stick, canceled that and now tether to my phone. problem solved.

i mostly text and use data. the rare times i actually talk to someone, honestly, it's been embarrassing at times.

both my home and office are less than a km away from at least 1 tower, under 2km from 2.

overall though, i'm happy with the service, with the support, and with not paying rogers, telus, or bell.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,986 Posts
Discussion Starter #6 (Edited)
Great feedback from everyone.

I'm officially contract-free, and Wind is currently tops on my list of providers to switch to. The observations regarding reception quality being dependent on the phone model wasn't something I had considered.
 

·
Member #1
Joined
·
47,683 Posts
tezster, I'd also consider Mobilicity. I used it from Burlington to Downtown Toronto and had no problem with reception. I used a Blackberry Bold 9780
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
24,794 Posts
I have the Blackberry 9700 and use it daily from Burlington to Toronto commute. A small dead zone in Mississauga but the rest is fine, including in office towers in downtown T.O.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,986 Posts
Discussion Starter #9
I haven't made a final decision yet, and Mobilicity is "in the mix" of providers I'm thinking of switching to. However, if the Canadian Cell Tower finder is accurate, their nearest tower is 4km from my home, which worries me. I'm on the extreme western edge of their coverage map (west of Winston Churchill), so their current coverage may not work out for me.
 

·
Member #1
Joined
·
47,683 Posts
Just thought I would throw the suggestion out there.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
102 Posts
My experience with Wind was pretty bad (Somerset, Calgary and downtown Vancouver).

I would take their map and roll back the boundary by 4-5 km.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
25 Posts
Hi guys im new to the wind network as well only been a couple of weeks. Im in the brampton/etobicoke area mostly and have to say over all the coverage has been pretty good. Im using the g2x from tmobile on the network and so far no dropped calls. There have been a few spots where i get no signal in certain buildings or areas but usually only infrequently. I am not a big phone user so for me the call quality has been quite good given the limited time ive spent talking. As for data well again its been pretty good this is my first foray into the smartphone market so truly i dont really know the speeds of whats out there but for what i need its been pretty good . using the home wifi also boosts signal for times when you really need that extra oompf.
Cant argue with the pricing though and im sure their network coverage being still a fledgling carrier will only get better. There are instances when my daughters blackberry switched to wind away while in a wind zone and had to pay for that. knowing this i set my phone to roaming off because who wants to pay more for something you have paid for already.
Hope it helps and i will say that for me the wind experience , esp the customer service has been very smooth and uncomplicated
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,818 Posts
Yes, I'd recommend setting your phone to manual network selection and set it to wind home.
Chances are you will not drop out of it except in the odd spot (e.g. inside a concrete building) that the signal can't quite get to.

Often phones will switch to roaming when there is still usable signal, because that's in their programming.
E.g. my phone on manual will work down to 0 bars.
If I had it on automatic, it would have switched when it reached zero bars, despite there being usable signal.

That's an extreme case, though. (My basement)
Normally if you're outside you would never get that low if you're within the known coverage area. Indoors is highly dependent on the structure type and surrounding terrain/buildings
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
611 Posts
Once you get west of Mississauga, Wind coverage is generally excellent..

I've primarily used my Wind phone in Burlington, Oakville and Hamilton, and I've yet to have a call dropped.
 

·
Super Moderator
Joined
·
3,996 Posts
I've found their downtown coverage to be excellent, particularly in the past few months as they've been making significant improvements to the downtown network.

In the east end, I've found coverage to be hit or miss. Sometimes it's great, but there are still some areas where you'll barely have signal outdoors, let alone in buildings.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1 Posts
I'd like to hear some general experiences from existing Wind Mobile subscribers regarding network coverage in the GTA (I'm most interested in the west end of Mississauga), including call quality/dropped calls and building penetration i.e. office buildings, basements.

My longtime contract with Rogers is finally expiring, and in exploring what the various (newer) mobile carriers have to offer, Wind appears to have what I'm looking for from a plan and pricing standpoint. However, in doing my diligence in terms of online research, the opinions I've read (in other forums and the Wind community pages) have been quite mixed in terms of network coverage.

I've checked coveragemapper, which looks ok in general, although there seem to be quite a few pockets of dead zones in Mississauga.
Run do not walk from wind. if you need humour - pass wind. poor coverage; awful service.
 
1 - 17 of 17 Posts
Top