Remote automation controls help needed

If you can give us a better idea as to how much you want to spend we will be able to get you into products that will suit that budget.


I am currently programming a Crestron system to communicate with a GE Security system via both local and remote access.

I'd like to be able to:
- sense and control temp inside the house
- sense temp outside the house
- sense temp in a pumphouse (about 300' from the house)
- know if the power is out
- sense if there is water in the basement
- light controls would be nice (I can deal with webcams etc)
- maybe a remote motion sensor to know if someone is in the house

Click to expand...

For Temperature sensing Crestron makes temp sensors as well as thermostats to allow you to control your house temp with any furnace.

Power sensing can be done a few ways, the best way is with some kind of battery backup system like a Security system or a Smart UPC that also talks to a control system. Most smart UPC's also allow for control of outlets so you can kills the power to any devices that don't require it when you are not there.

Water level and any security information (ie doors/windows and motions) are controlled by the GE security system.

Lighting can be controlled by a variety of different companies and can also be programmed into the crestron system but I would suggest using crestron lighting modules as there is little to no programming as it is pre-built and allows the end user to create "scenes" and schedulers.

The GE Security system and Crestron system talk to each other via RS232.

There is also a Paradox security system that will allow for remote access but does not allow for temperature/lighting controls.

I know the cost of Crestron is fairly high and you would need to find a company in your area that sells the full crestron line to talk to them.

Take a look at the elk systems, Everything you want to do can be done with out too much trouble. It will take a bit of learning to be DIY but so will anything. With the Elk you have two options, either the M1 gold or the M1ez8 depending on your future needs and connectivity objectives. I think for the difference in price the gold is the way to go. BUT either should get you up and running without too much hassle. The nice thing is you could test wire everything here in town with short leads and get it all programmed and ready to go so when you go to the cabin you just run the wires and reconnect everything so its much less stress trying to figure everything out.

Programing them is pretty straight forward and can be done via the internet or locally connected to it. I do all mine over the network.

From what you want to do there are many different approaches but this is a quick idea for your setup. With going light control I think you might be slighly over budget but not too much depending on what thermostat you choose for your system.

-Elk M1gold main system
-Elk M1XEP If you want to control your system with regular internet
-HAI Ominstart 2 thermostat or other meant for Heatpumps
-2 external temp sensors
-power sensor is built in to the elk I believe you just create an event notification
-Water bug sensor
-light control you can go many routes and just choose the interface you want
-motion sensors, door sensors,glass breakage etc regular security sensors for what ever you could possibly want. If you have recording web cams you can even have it to automate sending you the last few minutes of screen captures to you if say the door sensor or glass breakage goes off.
-listen in modules and voice modules are available too

When I looked into control systems for the office I looked at control4, and while i liked the polished interface I did not like that the resellers did not want to allow me control of the system after it was installed. So any small changes I would have to contact them. And well the cost was WAY more than Elk and with less out of the box functionality.

Wayne, are you able to freely configure your system? And how was your exprience with the reseller? the resellers here in Calgary were useless when it came to getting access to the needed software and even more useless when I would ask about custom automation commands ,

"can we make it notify me by email or txt if the alarm is tripped and send the last 15 seconds of video for the closest camera to the affected zone to my phone right away?"

Their answer, well Im not sure let us do some reading and get back to you. I was in Awe of thier lack of knowledge on their products. I had a list of about 10 specific questions and only a few could be answered right away.

ctown6412 said:

When I looked into control systems for the office I looked at control4, and while i liked the polished interface I did not like that the resellers did not want to allow me control of the system after it was installed. So any small changes I would have to contact them. And well the cost was WAY more than Elk and with less out of the box functionality.

Wayne, are you able to freely configure your system? And how was your exprience with the reseller?

Click to expand...

Control4 is not as DIY as I would like it to be but it is pretty good. There are two versions of the programming software Composer - the professional edition and the home edition.

The home edition does 99% of what the professional system does. The main difference is that you cannot add hardware to your system. That wouldn't be an issue to me if it meant that I need to call me dealer to add in a new light switch, as I don't do my own wiring, but it also means that you have to call in a dealer if you get a new DVD player and want to integrate it into your system.

With the home edition I can program all of the switches in the house, I can have one switch in my bedroom turn off all other switches, I can have a double click do something else, etc. You can also have the system send you email notifications on any type of event, such as a temperature being over or under a threshold, motion sensors being activated, lights turning on/off, etc without requiring your dealer. There are even things like Twitter addins that will tweet when certain events happen.

My dealer is pretty good but he is an electrician dabbling in the home automation space and I don't think he really understood how to to do more complex programming nor how to properly place the controller in my LAN given my router, switches, cable modem, etc.

FYI - I use Control4 to control my lighting, HVAC systems, automated blinds and one gas fireplace. Many people use it much more for things like automating their A/V system, and have it set up with fancy video matrix switches, etc. But I prefer using a centralized HTPC server with SageTV extenders at all PCs - that way the A/V content is delivered to five TVs in my house (and several PCs) via ethernet rather than other specialized cabling.

You can also get Control4 apps for iPhone/iPad that allows you to use these as controllers - this is somewhat changing their business model as Control4 used to charge something like $1500 for touch screens - it is hard to do that when you can buy an iPad for $500 that has much additional functionality. They were initially charging something like $200 to activate the iPhone app but I believe they have no gone to a subscription model.

Control4 also refuses to release a PC based front end to control their system although you can do much of the Control through the programming tool, just not in a very user friendly way.

p.s. By the way I have heard rumours that some Control4 customers have been able to obtain copies of the professional edition of the software through various file-sharing sites, etc.