Canadian TV, Computing and Home Theatre Forums banner

1 - 19 of 19 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
8 Posts
Discussion Starter #1
I've had a Linksys WRT54GS for six years running my home network of 3-6 computers and smartphones depending on how many of my teenagers are home. I figure it's time to upgrade to a new wifi router (and it seems N is the way to go these days). I will continue to have 3 wired connections in the study where the router sits. What I would like to do is disable the wifi for certain periods of the day, but still be able to use the wired ports for connection to Internet.

I looked at several threads, vendor sites, and smallnetbuilder.com for any detail on a wifi router feature that actually disables the wireless transmission. Can anyone confirm if there is such a router with a switch or config setting that allows wifi transmission to be turned off ?

I have added a simple device timer and have it set so the router is off and not transmitting all day - but then I also loose the wired ports when it's off.

I have Rogers Hi-Speed Express and last month they tried to get me to upgrade to their $199 "enhanced wifi modem" and told me that it was possible to turn off the wifi. It appears to be a CISCO DP 3825 router and modem device, that does have a menu to allow disabling of wireless. The device and price are more than I need so I would like to know if other wifi routers have a similar feature. A physical switch or button would be preferred to a login and menu item, but I'll take either.

Why am I doing this ? Well I'm not looking for a debate on whether non-ionizing EMR is truly harmful or not, but I am also trying to moderate my families constant exposure to EMR in the home. Disabling wireless transmission for the many hours that wifi is not required in the day is one step I want to take.

thanks.
 

·
Super Moderator
Joined
·
56,403 Posts
I have Rogers Hi-Speed Express
You're not going to have much choice. See the following thread on the D3 modems - read the last few pages.

http://www.digitalhome.ca/forum/showthread.php?t=145997

I have my D3 modem in bridged mode and use an Airport Extreme. As discussed in that thread, the routers do not have a very good range, but may do depending on your application. You'll also see the pricing is $149 if you pick it up yourself.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
8 Posts
Discussion Starter #6
is keeping my D2 a viable option if I add Airport Extreme?

thanks gents for the very helpful links and guidance. I've read much more and slowly learning the technology and options. I still have a Motorolla Surfboard SB5101 which I understand is "D2" and therefore I'm going to be gated at 10 Mbps on my Rogers Express.

In summary what I learned:
- Rogers doesn't offer a standalone D3 modem
- Rogers gateway devices are not the best options as routers
- Airport Extreme is a very intriguing option for my reqts since it has wired ports, timer sw feature to disable wifi, printer port.
- get Rogers to put your gateway device in bridge mode after you set it up

I'm inclined to follow 57's lead and buy the SMC D3 (N), put it in bridge mode, add Airport Extreme.

I'd like to ask if it is feasible to stay with my Motorolla D2 and still replace my Linksys WRT54G with the Airport Extreme ? Can the D2 be placed in bridge mode ? (I realize in this setup I may still be stuck at 10Mbps speed).

thanks
 

·
Super Moderator
Joined
·
56,403 Posts
You can run with the Surfboard D2 modem connected to the Airport Extreme. I did that for years. The Surfboard is just a modem, not a router. You will be stuck at the lower speeds/caps. I'm not sure if Rogers still sells the SMC, but it doesn't really matter what you get from Rogers if you get a D3 gateway to put in bridge mode. I found the additional download and upload speeds associated with D3 to be worthwhile and I don't even download that much. The difference in download is a factor of 2.5 now.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
20 Posts
TP-Link routers can also do schedule out of the box if you don't want to go thirdparty firmware via dd-wrt/gargoyle(openwrt)/tomato.
I imagine other vendors are similar.

Here's a link to an online simulator of the TP-Link router web admin interface:
Link to TP-Link simulator
  • Schedule can be found under Access control.
I'd also scout reviews on smallnetbuilder to make sure whatever router you choose an support the internet speeds you have or wish to upgrade to. ;)
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,040 Posts
Do you have any devices that support 802.11N? If not, upgrading to a new modem will not provide you with any immediate improvements. OTOH, you could install DD-WRT on your existing modem to get the time block function you are looking for (and lots of performance improvements)
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
4,666 Posts
I have an Asus N66 and can turn the radios off with a push button on the router as well through custom firmware (both by schedule or toggle).



As well, I have Netgear I'm using as an access point that is running DD-WRT and can do radio scheduling there as well. Any DD-WRT compatible router should be able to do it.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
8 Posts
Discussion Starter #12
disabling the wifi broadcasting as opposed to blocking users

Tikker is correct - I am looking for a solution to turn off the wifi radio transmission based on a schedule, and possibly with a button.

The trick is that when the wifi is off, I'd still like the wired ports to be providing Internet access. This is why options that shut off the router completely are not ideal. I already have that now with the simple timer on my Linksys WRT54G but that of course kills the wired ports as well.

I'm going to look into the ASUS N66 johnnyCanuck suggests.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
832 Posts
I have two D-Link routers (DGL4100 and 855 ) and they both support Wi-Fi radio togglef on schedule. I have enabled this feature on both units to extend the life of the radios ehich tend to loose both in range and speed after years of continuous duty.

May not be the case with other brands but it certainly is noticeable with D-Link.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,101 Posts
The trick is that when the wifi is off, I'd still like the wired ports to be providing Internet access.
I've got an asus RT-N56U that you can schedule the wifi radio easily as well. the neat part that I liked, is that you can do it for each radio independently (2.4 and 5.0 ghz )

This way I put all the kids on the 2.4 radio, the adults on 5.0 and can independently cut their internet access at bedtime


Wireless - Professional (2.4GHz)
Wireless Professional Setting allows you to set up additional parameters for wireless. But default values are recommended.
Enable Radio? Yes No
Date to Enable Radio: Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
Time of Day to Enable Radio: : - :
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
8 Posts
Discussion Starter #16
thanks Tikker. I've been on ASUS website and looked at the UI and it seems easy to use.
The RT-N56U is less expensive than the Airport Extreme and seems to have all the features (ie 4 wired ports, printer port) that I need.

Since I'll have the radio off for periods of the day, I'll have to use one of my wired Windows servers to go in and turn it back on outside of the timer schedule.
I didn't see Mac OS as an option on their download site so I'm going to assume I can't use my wired iMac to access the UI.

thanks.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
350 Posts
Want schedule similar to DIR-655

I liked the WiFi schedule that was supported by the D-Link DIR-655, but always hated the router because it required rebooting all the time. We have the Rogers router now which doesn't support schedules, so I want to put it in bridge mode and buy a separate router that supports WiFi scheduling.

I am gun-shy re: going back to a DIR-655, because I want a router that doesn't require constant rebooting.

Any suggestions?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
8,614 Posts
Just about anything but a D-Link is better. Asus has some very nice routers. The RT56 and RT66 models are good performers and have lots of features. I don't see any scheduling options for the RT-N66U in access point mode. It probably has them in router mode (which is what you want) but it's worth checking out. It will also flash with DD-WRT firmware which definitely does scheduling (and lots more.)
 
1 - 19 of 19 Posts
Top