Canadian TV, Computing and Home Theatre Forums - View Single Post - Cellphone firms ordered to fix 911 system to save lives

View Single Post
post #6 of (permalink) Old 2009-01-10, 03:35 PM
Join Date: Sep 2005
Location: Thornhill, ON
Posts: 747
Despite The Globe and Mail's sensational headline, it is very doubtful that the enhanced 9-1-1 service would have made any difference in the sad Williams Lake incident. In order for GPS locating to work, three signal sources are required. A quick look at the wireless towers site map reveals Telus and Rogers each have one tower in/near Williams Lake. Assuming the victim's phone had power to keep sending a signal, the best that could have been done would have been to locate him to within about a 50km radius of Williams Lake, something the RCMP no doubt could have surmised without the aid of any big-city newspaper reporters or modern technology. The Globe's source for its story and headline was the victim's 17 year old girlfriend and apparently no attempt was made to contact Telus/Rogers to corroborate the theory.

The death is sad, but not as sad as the future lives that will be lost because headline hunting, ad-revenue chasing newspapers have mislead readers to believe their cell-phone is a remote GPS device capable of sending their location to emergency personnel. I am sorry the victim's family and friends and this tragedy are being used to sell newspapers.

Nothing sinister should be assumed because a death by other than obvious natural causes is referred to the coroner or that the RCMP will provide their evidence to the coroner rather than the media.
outinthornhill is offline  
For the best viewing experience please update your browser to Google Chrome