I'm located near Clover & Mchugh (2 mins from riverside drive) and have absolutely no issues picking up Toledo. I pick up WTOL, WTVG, WGTE, WNWO basically 100% of the time. The only station that is hard to pickup is Fox - WUPW. I am using a combo antenna designed for the new 7-51 band, an antenna craft HBU 33 along with the same antennacraft pre-amp you're using. I have it roof mounted, but the difference may be that being a new sub division there is no trees anywhere near... do you have any obstructions?
Antennacraft HBU33, Antennacraft 10G201 preamp, Samsung PN50A650 Plasma, Samsung LN40B540 LCD.