![]() |
|
|
|
|
|
|||||||
![]() |
|
|
Thread Tools | Search this Thread | Display Modes | |
|
|
||||
|
|
#1 |
|
Join Date: Feb 2011
Location: Cookeville, TN, USA
Posts: 162
|
I have an old Channel Masters Crossfire CM-3672 I believe.
I would like to get some feedback on removing the uhf portion. About 4 or 5 months ago refurbished the antenna and since have acquired a CM-4251 so want to modify the Crossfire for VHF only. My idea was to remove the matching bars and uhf reflectors. I originally thought I was going to be able to remove the whole uhf section but there are vhf elements on that section. Does anyone think removing the uhf elements themselves will hurt the antenna for vhf only? If not I wanted to use those to make a small uhf antenna to point in the opposite direction for a local station that is almost 180 degrees from my Nashville stations. Here is my antenna. There are 2 other photos here https://picasaweb.google.com/1069450...eat=directlink My other question is will running 300ohm twinlead from this antenna to the CM-4251 then from those lugs attach a balun which will then go to my Winegard AP-8780. Will this work or will it hurt reception? I figure that I would be better off getting a UVSJ to combine them. Any comments appreciated. |
|
|
| Sponsored Links | |||
Advertisement | |||
|
|
#2 | |
|
Veteran
Join Date: Mar 2008
Location: Somewhere in Delaware on the flat side
Posts: 7,011
|
Quote:
There may be vhf-hi directors on the corner reflector, Im not sure. How long are those longest reflectors on the corner reflector ? Ive modeled taking off the uhf sections (and vhf-low elements ) on antennas like the Radio Shack VU series, which are similar LPDA's with the cross over phasing lines, like yours. Slicing and dicing works out well with those type of antennas. Double boom or vee boom type LPDAs are a different story. brantford bill is taking off the uhf section of a Channel Master kind of like yours, but a bit smaller. Starting with post 551 here : http://www.digitalhome.ca/forum/show...107706&page=37 He seems to have run into a problem. Whether the balun is broken or that he needed to leave the flat metal folded dipole (in your case, that would be the flat metal bowtie) on because it serves as a termination device, I dont know.
__________________
My builds/plans (not the latest models) are located here. |
|
|
|
|
|
#3 |
|
Join Date: Feb 2011
Location: Cookeville, TN, USA
Posts: 162
|
I don't see any vhf directors on the reflector booms.
If you look at my Picasa photo album I linked to you will see that my antenna has matching tubes instead of wires like Brantford_Bill's antenna. Although I'm baffled as to what those bars are for on his UHF folded dipole are. I'm assuming it attaches to another dipole or something. I think if I remove my matching tubes and connect to the VHF dipole connection point instead of the UHF connection point that I connect to right now I think mine will work that way. My other question is will the connection from there to the CM-4251 then subsequently to the pre-amp via a balun. will it work and not degrade the signal of the combining of the 2 antennas? |
|
|
|
|
#4 | ||
|
Veteran
Join Date: Mar 2008
Location: Somewhere in Delaware on the flat side
Posts: 7,011
|
Quote:
Quote:
__________________
My builds/plans (not the latest models) are located here. |
||
|
|
|
|
#5 |
|
Join Date: Feb 2011
Location: Cookeville, TN, USA
Posts: 162
|
I don't have any 450ohm ladder available...I do have a few feet of 300 ohm from when I acquired the 4251 and another old really beat up CM antenna which I disassembled.
I guess I will see if I can acquire a UVSJ locally, if not I will have to order one and wait for it. I do have a preamp but it isn't in those pictures as I hadn't acquired it yet when I took those pictures. In fact that antenna is now about 10 feet higher than it is in those pictures and has 3 guide wires attached. It is also before I refurbished that antenna too. When I refurbished the antenna and added the pre-amp and raised it up I increased my reception. What I'm trying to achieve is get better reception on channel 23 (virtual 58.1 & 58.2) which doesn't come in reliably right now. My other issue is I need the VHF low and hi cause I recieve 5, 8 & 10 so I need to keep the VHF portion of this antenna. Finding VHF only antennas for 2 to 13 are few and far between and cost more than I'm willing to spend right now. This antenna feeds 2 television and a Hdhomerun reciever for my Mythbox. |
|
|
|
|
#6 | ||
|
Veteran
Join Date: Mar 2008
Location: Somewhere in Delaware on the flat side
Posts: 7,011
|
Quote:
Quote:
http://www.digitalhome.ca/forum/show...ghlight=cm4251
__________________
My builds/plans (not the latest models) are located here. |
||
|
|
|
|
#7 |
|
Join Date: Feb 2011
Location: Cookeville, TN, USA
Posts: 162
|
I live in Cookeville, TN
I can't tell if the dip is worse than my existing antenna. If it is just a little better I would be happy. If it ends up worse than I will make the wife very unhappy as she is happy with it now. |
|
|
|
|
#8 |
|
Veteran
Join Date: Mar 2008
Location: Somewhere in Delaware on the flat side
Posts: 7,011
|
Ideally, what you want is a CM0264 preamp like what I have. (seem to be hard to get now) It has separate 300 ohm inputs for uhf and vhf, and a 75 ohm output, low noise and durable.
__________________
My builds/plans (not the latest models) are located here. |
|
|
|
|
#9 |
|
Join Date: Feb 2011
Location: Cookeville, TN, USA
Posts: 162
|
Probably but I got this Winegard AP-8780 and haven't been disappointed.
I think I have a local source for the UVSJ that is if Kmart has them at the store. If not I don't know where I can get one locally and will probably order 1 or 2 from SolidSignal which seems to be a good price of less than 2 dollars each. |
|
|
|
|
#10 |
|
Join Date: Feb 2011
Location: Cookeville, TN, USA
Posts: 162
|
I added some more pictures to my picasa album that might help make a better assessment.
Appreciate your help 300ohm I didn't find a UVSJ locally so I'm going to have to order one...so might order a couple or more considering SolidSignal has them pretty cheap. |
|
|
|
|
#11 | ||||
|
Veteran
Join Date: Mar 2008
Location: Somewhere in Delaware on the flat side
Posts: 7,011
|
Quote:
Quote:
![]() I put the letters and numbers in there for future reference. The red dot is the balun connection point. The spacing at A, the distance between the last front active element and the first director, is 14 inches measured center of tube to center of tube. Can you compare this to yours ? Its a pretty critical dimension and hopefully yours is very close to the same distance. Quote:
http://www.hdtvprimer.com/ANTENNAS/comparing.html Quote:
__________________
My builds/plans (not the latest models) are located here. |
||||
|
|
|
|
#12 |
|
Veteran
Join Date: Mar 2008
Location: Somewhere in Delaware on the flat side
Posts: 7,011
|
The NEC file:
Code:
CM CM3671 : Channel Master 3671B, converted with 4nec2 on 25-Nov-08 12:47 CM Ken Nist CM-3671 model with UHF relevant pieces removed by 300 ohm CM AGT = .99 (0db) at 195mhz, Auto Segmentation = 21 CE GW 8 75 0.95 53.8 0.5 0.95 -53.8 0.5 0.1875 GW 9 67 13 -47.7 0.5 13 47.7 0.5 0.1875 GW 10 61 24.9 44.15 0.5 24.9 -44.15 0.5 0.1875 GW 11 59 37 -41.6 0.5 37 41.6 0.5 0.1875 GW 12 55 49 38.6 0.5 49 -38.6 0.5 0.1875 GW 13 49 61 -35.6 0.5 61 35.6 0.5 0.1875 GW 14 45 73 32.2 0.5 73 -32.2 0.5 0.1875 GW 15 41 85 -29.15 0.5 85 29.15 0.5 0.1875 GW 16 1 92 0.3 0.5 92 -0.3 0.5 0.075 GW 17 5 97 1.8 0.8 92 0.3 0.5 0.075 GW 18 5 97 -1.8 0.8 92 -0.3 0.5 0.075 GW 19 17 97 1.8 0.8 97 26.6 0.8 0.075 GW 20 17 97 -1.8 0.8 97 -26.6 0.8 0.075 GW 23 23 4.85 16.1 1.2 4.85 -16.1 1.2 0.1875 GW 24 23 16.9 15.6 1.2 16.9 -15.6 1.2 0.1875 GW 25 21 28.5 14.5 1.2 28.5 -14.5 1.2 0.1875 GW 26 21 40.5 14.3 1.2 40.5 -14.3 1.2 0.1875 GW 27 19 52.5 13.5 1.2 52.5 -13.5 1.2 0.1875 GW 28 19 64.5 13 1.2 64.5 -13 1.2 0.1875 GW 29 19 76 13 1.2 76 -13 1.2 0.1875 GW 30 17 88 12.3 1.2 88 -12.3 1.2 0.1875 GW 31 17 99.9 12.1 -0.75 99.9 -12.1 -0.75 0.1875 GW 33 15 111 7 -0.7 111 28.2 -0.7 0.1875 GW 34 15 111 -7 -0.7 111 -28.2 -0.7 0.1875 GW 171 1 126.65 -6.5 1 126.65 -7.75 1 0.1875 GW 172 13 126.65 -8.5 1 126.65 -26.4 1 0.1875 GW 173 1 126.65 -7.75 1 126.65 -8.5 1 0.1875 GW 174 1 126.65 -7.75 1 127.74 -7.75 1 0.06 GW 175 1 126.65 -8.5 1 127.34 -8.5 1 0.06 GW 176 1 128.99 -12.3 1 128.24 -12.3 1 0.06 GW 177 1 128.99 -9.98 1 128.24 -10.14 1 0.06 GW 178 3 128.99 -12.3 1 128.99 -9.98 1 0.06 GW 179 1 128.24 -12.3 1 128.24 -10.14 1 0.06 GW 180 3 128.99 -9.98 1 127.74 -7.75 1 0.06 GW 181 1 128.24 -10.14 1 127.34 -8.5 1 0.06 GW 182 1 127.34 -8.5 1 127.74 -7.75 1 0.06 GW 183 1 126.65 -7.75 1 125.56 -7.75 1 0.06 GW 184 1 126.65 -8.5 1 125.96 -8.5 1 0.06 GW 185 1 124.31 -12.3 1 125.06 -12.3 1 0.06 GW 186 1 124.31 -9.98 1 125.06 -10.14 1 0.06 GW 187 3 124.31 -12.3 1 124.31 -9.98 1 0.06 GW 188 1 125.06 -12.3 1 125.06 -10.14 1 0.06 GW 189 3 124.31 -9.98 1 125.56 -7.75 1 0.06 GW 190 1 125.06 -10.14 1 125.96 -8.5 1 0.06 GW 191 1 125.96 -8.5 1 125.56 -7.75 1 0.06 GW 192 1 126.65 6.5 1 126.65 7.75 1 0.1875 GW 193 13 126.65 8.5 1 126.65 26.4 1 0.1875 GW 194 1 126.65 7.75 1 126.65 8.5 1 0.1875 GW 195 1 126.65 7.75 1 127.74 7.75 1 0.06 GW 196 1 126.65 8.5 1 127.34 8.5 1 0.06 GW 197 1 128.99 12.3 1 128.24 12.3 1 0.06 GW 198 1 128.99 9.98 1 128.24 10.14 1 0.06 GW 199 3 128.99 12.3 1 128.99 9.98 1 0.06 GW 200 1 128.24 12.3 1 128.24 10.14 1 0.06 GW 201 3 128.99 9.98 1 127.74 7.75 1 0.06 GW 202 1 128.24 10.14 1 127.34 8.5 1 0.06 GW 203 1 127.34 8.5 1 127.74 7.75 1 0.06 GW 204 1 126.65 7.75 1 125.56 7.75 1 0.06 GW 205 1 126.65 8.5 1 125.96 8.5 1 0.06 GW 206 1 124.31 12.3 1 125.06 12.3 1 0.06 GW 207 1 124.31 9.98 1 125.06 10.14 1 0.06 GW 208 3 124.31 12.3 1 124.31 9.98 1 0.06 GW 209 1 125.06 12.3 1 125.06 10.14 1 0.06 GW 210 3 124.31 9.98 1 125.56 7.75 1 0.06 GW 211 1 125.06 10.14 1 125.96 8.5 1 0.06 GW 212 1 125.96 8.5 1 125.56 7.75 1 0.06 GW 213 1 137.13 -6.5 1 137.13 -7.75 1 0.1875 GW 214 13 137.13 -8.5 1 137.13 -26.4 1 0.1875 GW 215 1 137.13 -7.75 1 137.13 -8.5 1 0.1875 GW 216 1 137.13 -7.75 1 138.22 -7.75 1 0.06 GW 217 1 137.13 -8.5 1 137.82 -8.5 1 0.06 GW 218 1 139.47 -12.3 1 138.72 -12.3 1 0.06 GW 219 1 139.47 -9.98 1 138.72 -10.14 1 0.06 GW 220 3 139.47 -12.3 1 139.47 -9.98 1 0.06 GW 221 1 138.72 -12.3 1 138.72 -10.14 1 0.06 GW 222 3 139.47 -9.98 1 138.22 -7.75 1 0.06 GW 223 1 138.72 -10.14 1 137.82 -8.5 1 0.06 GW 224 1 137.82 -8.5 1 138.22 -7.75 1 0.06 GW 225 1 137.13 -7.75 1 136.04 -7.75 1 0.06 GW 226 1 137.13 -8.5 1 136.44 -8.5 1 0.06 GW 227 1 134.79 -12.3 1 135.54 -12.3 1 0.06 GW 228 1 134.79 -9.98 1 135.54 -10.14 1 0.06 GW 229 3 134.79 -12.3 1 134.79 -9.98 1 0.06 GW 230 1 135.54 -12.3 1 135.54 -10.14 1 0.06 GW 231 3 134.79 -9.98 1 136.04 -7.75 1 0.06 GW 232 1 135.54 -10.14 1 136.44 -8.5 1 0.06 GW 233 1 136.44 -8.5 1 136.04 -7.75 1 0.06 GW 234 1 137.13 6.5 1 137.13 7.75 1 0.1875 GW 235 13 137.13 8.5 1 137.13 26.4 1 0.1875 GW 236 1 137.13 7.75 1 137.13 8.5 1 0.1875 GW 237 1 137.13 7.75 1 138.22 7.75 1 0.06 GW 238 1 137.13 8.5 1 137.82 8.5 1 0.06 GW 239 1 139.47 12.3 1 138.72 12.3 1 0.06 GW 240 1 139.47 9.98 1 138.72 10.14 1 0.06 GW 241 3 139.47 12.3 1 139.47 9.98 1 0.06 GW 242 1 138.72 12.3 1 138.72 10.14 1 0.06 GW 243 3 139.47 9.98 1 138.22 7.75 1 0.06 GW 244 1 138.72 10.14 1 137.82 8.5 1 0.06 GW 245 1 137.82 8.5 1 138.22 7.75 1 0.06 GW 246 1 137.13 7.75 1 136.04 7.75 1 0.06 GW 247 1 137.13 8.5 1 136.44 8.5 1 0.06 GW 248 1 134.79 12.3 1 135.54 12.3 1 0.06 GW 249 1 134.79 9.98 1 135.54 10.14 1 0.06 GW 250 3 134.79 12.3 1 134.79 9.98 1 0.06 GW 251 1 135.54 12.3 1 135.54 10.14 1 0.06 GW 252 3 134.79 9.98 1 136.04 7.75 1 0.06 GW 253 1 135.54 10.14 1 136.44 8.5 1 0.06 GW 254 1 136.44 8.5 1 136.04 7.75 1 0.06 GW 255 1 147.7 -6.5 1 147.7 -7.75 1 0.1875 GW 256 13 147.7 -8.5 1 147.7 -26.4 1 0.1875 GW 257 1 147.7 -7.75 1 147.7 -8.5 1 0.1875 GW 258 1 147.7 -7.75 1 148.79 -7.75 1 0.06 GW 259 1 147.7 -8.5 1 148.39 -8.5 1 0.06 GW 260 1 150.04 -12.3 1 149.29 -12.3 1 0.06 GW 261 1 150.04 -9.98 1 149.29 -10.14 1 0.06 GW 262 3 150.04 -12.3 1 150.04 -9.98 1 0.06 GW 263 1 149.29 -12.3 1 149.29 -10.14 1 0.06 GW 264 3 150.04 -9.98 1 148.79 -7.75 1 0.06 GW 265 1 149.29 -10.14 1 148.39 -8.5 1 0.06 GW 266 1 148.39 -8.5 1 148.79 -7.75 1 0.06 GW 267 1 147.7 -7.75 1 146.61 -7.75 1 0.06 GW 268 1 147.7 -8.5 1 147.01 -8.5 1 0.06 GW 269 1 145.36 -12.3 1 146.11 -12.3 1 0.06 GW 270 1 145.36 -9.98 1 146.11 -10.14 1 0.06 GW 271 3 145.36 -12.3 1 145.36 -9.98 1 0.06 GW 272 1 146.11 -12.3 1 146.11 -10.14 1 0.06 GW 273 3 145.36 -9.98 1 146.61 -7.75 1 0.06 GW 274 1 146.11 -10.14 1 147.01 -8.5 1 0.06 GW 275 1 147.01 -8.5 1 146.61 -7.75 1 0.06 GW 276 1 147.7 6.5 1 147.7 7.75 1 0.1875 GW 277 13 147.7 8.5 1 147.7 26.4 1 0.1875 GW 278 1 147.7 7.75 1 147.7 8.5 1 0.1875 GW 279 1 147.7 7.75 1 148.79 7.75 1 0.06 GW 280 1 147.7 8.5 1 148.39 8.5 1 0.06 GW 281 1 150.04 12.3 1 149.29 12.3 1 0.06 GW 282 1 150.04 9.98 1 149.29 10.14 1 0.06 GW 283 3 150.04 12.3 1 150.04 9.98 1 0.06 GW 284 1 149.29 12.3 1 149.29 10.14 1 0.06 GW 285 3 150.04 9.98 1 148.79 7.75 1 0.06 GW 286 1 149.29 10.14 1 148.39 8.5 1 0.06 GW 287 1 148.39 8.5 1 148.79 7.75 1 0.06 GW 288 1 147.7 7.75 1 146.61 7.75 1 0.06 GW 289 1 147.7 8.5 1 147.01 8.5 1 0.06 GW 290 1 145.36 12.3 1 146.11 12.3 1 0.06 GW 291 1 145.36 9.98 1 146.11 10.14 1 0.06 GW 292 3 145.36 12.3 1 145.36 9.98 1 0.06 GW 293 1 146.11 12.3 1 146.11 10.14 1 0.06 GW 294 3 145.36 9.98 1 146.61 7.75 1 0.06 GW 295 1 146.11 10.14 1 147.01 8.5 1 0.06 GW 296 1 147.01 8.5 1 146.61 7.75 1 0.06 GW 297 3 97 -1.8 0.8 97 1.8 0.8 0.06 GS 0 0 0.0254 ' All in in. GE 0 EK TL 8 38 9 34 300 0.3556 TL 9 34 10 31 300 0.3556 TL 10 31 11 30 300 0.3556 TL 11 30 12 28 300 0.3556 TL 12 28 13 25 300 0.3556 TL 13 25 14 23 300 0.3556 TL 14 23 15 21 300 0.3556 TL 15 21 16 1 300 0.2032 LD 5 0 0 0 2.5e7 0 EX 0 297 2 0 1 0 GN -1 FR 0 1 0 0 195 0
__________________
My builds/plans (not the latest models) are located here. |
|
|
|
|
#13 |
|
Veteran
Join Date: Mar 2008
Location: Somewhere in Delaware on the flat side
Posts: 7,011
|
Hmm, I removed the Cap Hats off the directors. They are the U shaped pieces on those directors at 2, 3, 4 above. With Cap Hats off for channel 10 and no UHF elements, Raw Gain 10.8 dBi, SWR 1.36, Net Gain 10.7 dBi.
The Cap Hats do seem to play a significant role. But they should be easy enough to cut out from fairly thin sheet aluminum and pop rivet onto the director. The CM-4251 thread is here : http://www.digitalhome.ca/forum/show...ight=parabolas Basically, the only practical thing you can do to it to increase lower channel gain a bit is to increase the bowtie size out to the edge of the small reflector by pop riveting on some sheet aluminum.
__________________
My builds/plans (not the latest models) are located here. |
|
|
|
|
#14 |
|
Join Date: Feb 2011
Location: Cookeville, TN, USA
Posts: 162
|
I did take a closer look at the different pictures and your nec picture.
Your nec file shows 9 larger elements and 9 smaller elements behind where the UHF reflector was. The stock picture that I found of a CM-3671 shows 10 elements and 8 smaller elements behind where the UHF reflector was. On my antenna I count 11 larger elements and 9 smaller elements behind where the UHF reflector was. The missing elements for my antenna are one on the back and one around your reference mark A that are missing from your nec picture. If you added those elements then the balun connection point would be in the right spot. I have uploaded another picture that shows most of my antenna. I was hoping to do this conversion today but I might have to take some measurements and put it back up. I'm curious if a UVSJ would filter out the UHF signal on that antenna without converting at the present. My hope was to try the 4251 and see if my reception improved on channel 23 (58-1[2]) and if it did I was going to do the conversion and have it done in short order so my system wasn't down for more than an afternoon. I really do need to have the system back on by this (Saturday) evening. Of course by just removing the UHF reflector and elements it could increase the VHF and then I could add the directors on later. I could do that and take all the measurements of the antenna and then put it back up. I'm curious as to what the wings on those elements from the VHF antenna are for. Could they be some sort of Cap Hat? My antenna doesn't have the same front directors as the 3671 as you can see in the newly uploaded picture to my album. Thanks 300ohm for your help so far. |
|
|
|
|
#15 | |||
|
Veteran
Join Date: Mar 2008
Location: Somewhere in Delaware on the flat side
Posts: 7,011
|
Quote:
For measurements, this is a very good, concise way to do it, except it would be easier for me if the spacing measurements started from the back of the antenna instead of the front. ![]() Quote:
Quote:
__________________
My builds/plans (not the latest models) are located here. |
|||
|
|
![]() |
| Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
| Display Modes | |
|
|