About the Author and this thread - ARR is a former Shaw employee who worked for several years assisting the Star Choice team that developed and tested the Star Choice DVR530. He previously posted on the Digital Forum as digitaldude.
A little known fact is that ~ 30K 'special' dsr530's were shipped with the Seagate 250GB hard drives for in house use at a major N.A. auto manufacture that operates their own DCII transponder and had been using Moto DSR4XX units, but needed a DVR and the 530 was the ONLY DCII DVR around.
While its easy to criticize Moto/*C for selecting the 160GB, initial plans which I took over spec'ing originally had the 80GB and the 120GB was only a consideration as they were being used by the cable HD PVR's and only recently in the DCT6416 went to 160GB. I examined the cost and made a case for our current 160GB, so be thankful we got that.
So I replaced the original drive with a DB35 500(ST3500830ACE), after getting the 530 authorized it rebooted by itself about 15 minutes later. A slight panic with that! Then not a single glitch. It runs quieter, temperature on the old was usually 47, the new drive 44. I noticed jump back or forward has no image delay like the old drive. I didn't notice any other "speed" enhancements as of yet.
Its just nice having the extra hours (below 5 on the old one I would worry!) and faster skip function. Next up, the other 530 after another few months of testing with the current enhancement...
Will MPEG4 double the record time? If so, that would be a easy solution to all that have the 160 drive and would like to record more hours without having a drive upgrade.
I have also been extremely pleased with my 500Gb DB35. I wish a reliable source for the IDE flavor of this drive in 750GB would appear. They may well be no longer manufactured due to the demise of IDE overall versus SATA as commodity hard drives, but I'm watching Seagate closely to see if they can produce any more and get them into distribution.
The smoothness you are seeing is perhaps due to the large buffer on the drive. And the DB35s are very quiet, I agree.
There is simply no reason this drive should not be stock standard as a means to compete with Bell, et all.
If I understand correctly a larger drive will have have less seeking because of the larger cache and more platters.
So even though a standard 500G drive has a 10% greater power draw, than the original DB35 drive (according to the specs) since it is not being worked as hard it may end up generating the same or less heat?
It it worth the extra trouble and cost finding a DB35 drive or will a ST3500630A drive result in equal heat and noise performance of the stock 160G drive with more storage?
It seems to me that the 500G is the "sweet" spot from a price/capacity viewpoint.
A newer drive would be faster because of (typically) more cache memory, and the fact that more data passes under the read/write head per rotation -- not just because it may have more platters.
I went with the highest capacity I could. Not sure how long the larger drives will be around with everything moving to SATA. Haven't seen any issues reported with the non-DB35 750GB drives.
I am brand new here as of tonight, I have owned the 530 for a couple of years now. I have a warranty replacement approximately 1 1/2 years now which is locking up, timer issues etc at a rate that I am not happy with at all. SCR was prompt to call me back after I had emailed them and explained my dilemas then cited my current version 00.E4 was to be replaced this month as SC downloads between 1 and 5 am if the machine remains powered off, so far no upgrade. I am interested in this hard drive replacement as an alternative, I have read many success stories, or should I hold out for hope from SC? My apologies if this query is in the wrong thread, I'll get my DH legs soon...
Even the normal Seagate IDE drives are getting hard to find. I couldn't find any at my normal favourite B&M stores, so I had to order one online from canada computers. It shows OOS, but hopefully will be in soon.....
And the SAC doesn't care if a receiver on the account hasnt been hooked up for 6 months or 6 minutes. But dont leave your receivers unplugged for too long. It kills the batteries and corrupts the Unit Address.
I'm pretty sure hits get sent to your receiver around month end for your monthly programming.
Waiting 7 weeks for my drive from NCIX now. Starting to get worried that it will never come. Might have to consider some form of ata/sata adaptor set up if they stop ATA manufacturing.
Well, I got ored of waiting for my new 750 gig drive to come in, so I thought I would follow up with the idea of seeing if I could get an external USB drive to work. Well... success! And it was not hard to do either. I opened up the box and removed the drive as explained earlier in this thread. The connector inside connects up to a header on the board inside the machine. I pulled off the connector (off the drive and the board). I took a usb cord (one that connects to the motherboard header on a computer motherboard) and put it on the board header inside the 530.
A motherboard header will have 4 or 5 pins. The connector on the USB cord will have the same number of tiny holes to plug onto the pins. The 530 has 4 pins on it's connector. I was a little concerned because the hard drive cord inside the 530 has the green and red wires reversed from the computer USB cord I replaced it with. Turns out it didn't matter.
I decided that the best way to test this setup was to use the original drive in the external USB case. That way I could see if things were fully functional without going through the effort of factory resetting my machine.
I hooked it all up, plugged the usb external drive into the newly installed USB header cord and started it all up. Everything worked perfectly. I could access all my recorded shows, I recorded new material, and erased as well.
I did not test for hours to affirm stability, but I would be surprised if there would be any problems. So there you go. Great set up if you want to swap drives and have huge amounts of storage space (virtually unlimited actually). The only problem is the encryption. No other machine will read the drive, so if your machine dies, there goes your library.
Like I said in my last post... still waiting for my 750gig to come in. The thought of going through the effort to mirror the factory 160 to another spare drive just to see if it works seems like a lot of work if I don't plan to use the drive in the end. If it takes yet another week before my new drive comes, I might get bored again though. Who knows.
Has anyone tried this with a 505?
For someone considering subbing to SC, it sure would be better cost-wise for me to buy a 505, and then put in my own hard drive.
The remote and the s/w (greyed out DVR functions) for the 505 seems to indicate that it can be done.
It took me about 30-45 minutes to open the case, replace the drive and put it back together. I was taking my time and being cautious with removing the circuit board.
I didn't have any issues with the CSR. I just told them I had the unit unplugged for awhile.
I think it would perhaps be easier to just duplicate the old drive using Acronis or a sector by sector copy utility. The new drive should then work just like the old one.
FWW
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Related Threads
?
?
?
?
?
Canadian TV, Computing and Home Theatre Forums
1.7M posts
114.9K members
Since 2001
A forum community dedicated to Canadian TV, computing and home theatre owners and enthusiasts. Come join the discussion about home audio/video, displays, troubleshooting, styles, projects, DIY’s, product reviews, accessories, classifieds, and more!